Why Two Stone Oak Restaurant Corners Kept Swallowing Tenants, Until This Year
Skip Robinson had already sold four liquor stores in Colorado and six in South Texas before he decided to bet on a restaurant space that had chewed through six concepts in Stone Oak. "I had concerns," he told the San Antonio Report. "When people try something and are not successful, you've got to go in with your eyes wide open." He opened Stone Terrace Gastropub anyway. A few miles away on Stone Oak Parkway, a different owner was making the same bet on an even more notorious address, the old Frida space at 18740 Stone Oak Pkwy. This year, both bets are paying off. Both spaces had spent the better part of two decades proving that Stone Oak's dining scene wasn't short on foot traffic. It was short on the right idea.
If you've lived here through the last few restaurant turnovers, you already know the corners. What you may not have connected is why the same two addresses kept failing for the same underlying reason, and why the two operators who finally cracked it did the exact opposite of everyone before them.
Stone Oak Plaza, at the corner of Stone Oak Parkway and Loop 1604, had one real hit. Reggiano's ran there for roughly a decade before closing in 2009, and it's still the restaurant longtime residents bring up first. After that, the space could not hold a tenant. Watermark Grill came and went. So did Drew's American Grill and Buckles & Buns. CoCo Bongo lasted about a year. Frida Mexican Restaurant & Bar held on the longest of the post-Reggiano's group, four years, before closing in September 2024.
By the time Katerina signed the lease, the San Antonio Report had already started calling the address a graveyard, noting that for 16 years the nearly 10,000-square-foot space had buried one concept after another. Katerina opened quietly on February 9, 2026, backed by co-owners Dick Jones and Katerina Akimova and a kitchen led by chef Greg Carter, who has worked in Michelin-starred kitchens with Thomas Keller and José Andrés, and chef Justin Manzi, a Culinary Institute of America graduate with steakhouse experience at Morton's. The restaurant was already booked out for Valentine's Day and a wedding before its first month was over.
That kind of demand out of the gate isn't new for this corner. Frida did it too, for a while. The difference is what's happened since. As of this summer, OpenTable reviews still describe the restaurant with the same energy it opened with, calling it a "beautiful atmosphere" with "outstanding service," and Yelp reviewers are naming specific bartenders by name and coming back for happy hour, which runs Monday through Friday from 4 to 7 p.m. That's a different pattern than a launch spike. It's a repeat-visit habit, and repeat-visit habits are exactly what the five tenants between Reggiano's and Katerina never built.
Stone Oak has a second graveyard address, and it's less well known outside the neighborhood because none of its casualties made the same splash Frida did. Since 2008, the space now occupied by Stone Terrace Gastropub has gone through Ciel and Caio2, Cabo Seafood + Bar, Knife & Fork Gastropub, 1718 Steakhouse, Ace of Steaks, and White Rabbit, six concepts in all. Ace of Steaks is the one people still mention, mostly because of a $1,000 gold-plated Tomahawk steak that generated attention but couldn't keep the doors open past a year.
Robinson, a Navy veteran, took the space anyway and built the menu around food flights rather than a single signature dish. The pasta flight pairs filet mignon with mushroom ravioli, chicken parmesan mac and cheese, and a crab cake with mac and cheese. The beef Wellington, a dish that requires the pastry, the mushroom paste, and the tenderloin to all land correctly or the whole plate falls apart, has become one of the restaurant's most ordered items. Robinson told the San Antonio Report that word spread less through advertising and more through a local Facebook group, where he says roughly half his early tables mentioned seeing a post about the restaurant before their first visit.
Two graveyard corners, a few miles apart, both finally holding a tenant that's sticking. That's not a coincidence worth shrugging off. It's a pattern worth naming.
Here's the thing the "cursed corner" explanation misses: Reggiano's proved the location works. A restaurant does not run for a decade in a bad spot. Ace of Steaks proved that flash alone doesn't work. A restaurant does not need a viral steak stunt if it has repeat customers coming back for food that's simply good.
Every failed tenant between those two data points had a version of the same flaw. They were built around one loud idea, whether that was a theme, a gimmick dish, or an ambitious concept that looked good in a press release but didn't give a regular customer a reason to come back on a random Tuesday. Katerina and Stone Terrace Gastropub both did something different. Katerina built a menu wide enough to cover a date night, a happy hour, and a private dining event, and gave the space an atrium with a central tree and skylights that reads as an occasion without requiring one. Stone Terrace built a format, the flight, that's inherently repeatable because it lets a regular try something new without committing to a whole new dish.
Neither owner is claiming to have solved the corner permanently. Robinson said as much himself when he called it "a hard balance" between quality and cost. But the shift from single-idea concepts to repeatable ones is the clearest thread connecting both turnarounds, and it's the kind of detail that doesn't show up in a quick restaurant roundup. It shows up when you look at what actually failed and ask why.
For residents, the practical upside is straightforward. Two addresses that spent years as a rotating cast of openings and closures now have tenants that are behaving like they intend to stay. Katerina's patio and bar area get lively on weekends, but recent reviews describe Sunday evenings in the main dining room as the quieter option. Happy hour runs Monday through Friday from 4 to 7 p.m., which gives regulars a lower-cost way to test the menu before committing to a full dinner.
Stone Terrace leans more toward the group hangout than the occasion dinner. The flights format is built for sharing, and Robinson's own read on the neighborhood, that people want quality ingredients without a markup for flash, tracks with what finally worked after six other concepts didn't.
None of this guarantees either restaurant survives the next five years. Restaurant math is unforgiving everywhere, and both of these corners have humbled confident owners before. What's changed is that for the first time since Reggiano's closed in 2009, both graveyard addresses have tenants whose early numbers look like habit formation instead of a launch bump. That's worth knowing if you live nearby and have been waiting to see whether either place is worth a second visit, and it's worth knowing if you've simply wondered, the way most of us do when we drive past a familiar building with a new sign, what actually changed this time.
If you're the kind of Stone Oak resident who tracks these things, you already have your own list of what used to be where. Reggiano's regulars still talk about it. Frida had its own following before it closed. The corners remember more restaurants than most of us do, and that's part of what makes watching the next chapter worth doing.
M. Stagers Realty Partners works throughout Stone Oak and the surrounding Hill Country communities, and we like tracking the small changes that tell you a neighborhood is settling into something rather than just cycling through it. If you ever want to talk about what's changing here, or anywhere else we work in San Antonio, Start Your Journey with a conversation.
Our mission is to provide an experience that stands above the industry standard and challenges the status quo of the basic real estate agent. We want you to trust us as valuable real estate advisors, worthy of handling one of your largest purchases, sales or investments.
