An older ivory stucco cottage with a terracotta roof beside a broad lawn shaded by a mature live oak in Alamo Heights.

Older Alamo Heights Houses and the Builders Bidding on Them

In January 2024, the San Antonio Report wrote about a 1922 house at 231 Encino Ave. It called the house one of a growing number of older Alamo Heights homes headed for demolition. The 1.4-acre property was platted as two lots. The buyer, whose company is the builder Nic Abbey Homes, planned to build two houses there, and neighbors who wanted the Adams & Adams design saved spoke against the demolition. In April 2026 the address came back before the city's Architectural Review Board, this time as an application from Nic Abbey Homes, on behalf of owner Montclair Avenue LLC, for a new single-family home. The board recommended the design as compatible.

The city's own ARB results show the same pattern on ordinary streets in 2025 and 2026, with more cases each year. A buyer shopping for an older home in Alamo Heights this winter is often bidding against someone who prices the house as a teardown, not as a place to live.

What the city's docket shows since January 2025

Each month the Alamo Heights Architectural Review Board posts its results on alamoheightstx.gov. Every entry gives the address, the applicant, the owner and what was decided, so the results show which houses are coming down and who is asking.

From January 2025 through the October 20, 2026 meeting, the results list 17 different addresses where the applicant asked to demolish 100% of the existing house. Seven were docketed in 2025. Ten came in 2026, before November.

Year docketed Address Applicant named in the city results
2025 211 Kennedy Ave. Owner as applicant
2025 630 Tuxedo Ave. Dave Isaacs
2025 132 Normandy Ave. JCG Homes LLC
2025 328 Albany St. BB Puerto LLC
2025 503 Circle St., replaced by a duplex Manuel Luevanos
2025 727 Patterson Ave. Owner, Bardfield Properties LP
2025 123 Inslee Ave. Owner as applicant
2026 305 Argo Ave. Hearthside Homes Inc.
2026 310 Lamont Ave. MSA Architecture + Interiors
2026 215 Morse St. Myles Caudill
2026 607 Evans Ave. John J. Grable
2026 217 Corona Ave. Hearthside Homes Inc.
2026 126 College Blvd. Dave Isaacs Homes
2026 530 Corona Ave. Jay Corder
2026 200 Primrose Pl. Chesney Morales Partners
2026 131 Mary D Ave. Ella Bree Homes LLC
2026 138 Corona Ave. Owner as applicant

The list only goes up from there. In several other cases, the results name a builder and a new home but don't state how much of the old house would come down. Nic Abbey Homes had two of those on Grant Avenue, at 200 Grant in November 2025 and 216 Grant in June 2026. Caudill Homes and Build Modern LLC brought new-home designs for Retama Place and Harrison Avenue in 2025.

Almost all of these requests went through. In nearly every full-demolition case that reached a vote, the board found the existing house not significant and recommended the new design as compatible, sometimes with conditions or after a redesign. The closest vote was 3–1, for 123 Inslee Ave. in October 2025. On November 9, 2026, City Council approved three more cases 5–0: the full demolition at 138 Corona Ave., Ella Bree Homes' full demolition and new home at 131 Mary D Ave., and a partial façade demolition with an addition at 118 Routt St.

Why 2026 is the year to watch

Across the region, 2026 has been slow. The San Antonio Board of Realtors reported a $299,370 median sale price for October 2026, flat from a year earlier. Homes averaged 88 days on market, up 7%, and the region had 5.96 months of inventory. Those are metro figures, and they describe a market where buyers have time and leverage.

Alamo Heights demolitions moved the other way. By the October 20 meeting, ten full demolitions had been docketed in 2026, against seven in all of 2025. A softer regional market didn't slow the people tearing down and rebuilding in 78209. They are buying for the address, and the regional median says little about their budget.

How builders put a price on an older house

Hearthside Homes, a builder that appears twice in the 2026 docket, posts its numbers on its Alamo Heights and Terrell Hills page. It says most rebuilds in Alamo Heights and Terrell Hills run "from just under $1M to well over $2M." That price includes demolishing the existing house and all permit fees. It does not include the land. The same page offers to walk a property with a prospective buyer before purchase.

Builders are walking these houses before they go under contract, with a seven-figure construction budget already in mind. For that buyer, the existing house costs money to remove. What they will pay is the price of the lot. A family that wants to keep the 1940s cottage and update it values the same property by different math: the house is worth something, and the renovation budget sits on top.

The renovation side has its own published number. Virtuoso Builders lists an investment range of $650,000 to $800,000 for its "Alamo Heights Home Remastered" project, a transitional-style renovation that kept the existing house. One project isn't a market average. It does show that a serious renovation in this city can cost about as much as a modest rebuild, so a buyer planning to renovate and a builder planning to replace can bid near each other on the same house.

The partial demolitions are the other path

The docket includes owners who kept their houses and added on, and those cases are the clearest model for a buyer who wants an older home. Since January 2025, the board has reviewed partial demolitions at 305 Castano Ave., 630 W Castano Ave., 533 College Blvd., 216 Inslee Ave., 280 Tuxedo Ave., 202 Rosemary Ave. and 118 Routt St. Each kept the existing single-family home and added to it. These cases are described by percentage. At 280 Tuxedo, about 36% of the north-facing street façade and the entire roof were removed or encapsulated. At 202 Rosemary, it was about 38.7% of the west-facing street façade and about half the framing of the exterior walls.

These projects take time too. 118 Routt first appeared on the August 2026 agenda, was rescheduled more than once, and got its board recommendation on October 20 and its Council approval on November 9.

Where the preservation debate stands

Some neighbors have pushed back. The 2024 San Antonio Report story counted 75 Alamo Heights homes of various ages demolished over the previous five years and described residents working toward a historic district. In May 2026, the San Antonio Business Journal reported that the city had paused its historic-preservation effort, which began after a series of demolitions drew public backlash. While that effort is paused, the monthly ARB docket is the best public record of what is changing street by street. In 2026, it shows Corona Avenue with three cases and Grant Avenue with two.

What this means for a buyer

If you are comparing Alamo Heights with other close-in neighborhoods and you want an older house to live in and update, your competition may not be another family. On streets like Corona, Grant, Tuxedo and Inslee, assume a builder may also be looking. Hearthside sells its rebuilds under one fixed-price contract that runs from demolition to the finished home, so a builder can put a firm number on a lot. Older houses on larger or wider lots tend to draw this interest. 231 Encino, platted as two lots on 1.4 acres, is the clearest example from local reporting.

In practice, check a street's recent ARB history before you write an offer. If the next block has had new homes approved, the seller is probably already hearing from builders, and your offer will be judged against a land price. If you are selling an older home here, the same docket shows that builders are a real part of your buyer pool, and your pricing should reflect that. Our earlier guide to preparing a historic home for sale in 78209 covers the presentation side, and the Alamo Heights neighborhood page covers the area more broadly.

FAQ

Are Terrell Hills and Olmos Park part of this docket? No. The ARB results above cover the City of Alamo Heights only.

Do builders only go after large lots? The 2026 docket includes ordinary addresses on Argo, Lamont, Morse, Evans and College, so builders aren't limited to estate-sized parcels.

If you're deciding whether an older Alamo Heights house is one to keep, add on to or let go, and you want to know who else might be bidding, talk it through with M. Stagers Realty Partners before you make an offer. When you're ready to plan, Start Your Journey with us.

Buy or Sell with Us

Our mission is to provide an experience that stands above the industry standard and challenges the status quo of the basic real estate agent. We want you to trust us as valuable real estate advisors, worthy of handling one of your largest purchases, sales or investments.